Reading the national media on Open Banking, I get the sense of an impending cock-up of England World Cup football proportions .
That is tragic with something so important and radical. If – as it appears – the technocrats are writing the consumer narrative, then that is a very bad idea indeed.
Cock-up 1: The proposition
The consumer proposition is being obscured by a lack of focus. I see a jumble of information, messages and incoherence in the media. This is a mirror reflecting the reality of the complex project. But that is toxic as a consumer narrative.
I would recommend that communication be focused on the single, initially deliberately vague, simple message: “Open Banking will gradually improve financial opportunity for many people in the UK.”
Cock-up 2: The bait-the-banks strategy
The fintechies smelt the blood of the banks with the PSD2 and Open Banking regulations, but such fervent negativity is unnecessary. Open Banking is a huge cost to the banks, and a potential threat to their business, reducing their control over customer data and access to it. They have their pain. Let it be.
Fintech focus should switch from bank-baiting to delivering real applications and meaningful consumer benefits.
Cock-up 3: Too much regulation
Does anyone really understand where PSD2 stops and Open Banking starts? Now, add General Data Protection Regulation, with draconian new data protection, permissions, storing and usage rules and you're going to get potential conflict of regulations and interpretations.
Until this chaos gradually stabilises and clarifies, adopt a go-slow PR strategy.
Cock-up 4: Security
The banks have been told to share account data and have pointed out the inherent risks. So, at best, there is a grey area on accountability over data security. Even though data access is restricted to regulated third parties, consumer confidence in data protection is at rock bottom (and Meltdown and Spectre have fuelled the bonfire). Sharing more data simply magnifies risk, and consumers know that.
Right now is not the optimum moment to start promoting Open Banking aggressively. More beta testing is important here to make the security case more proven.
Cock-up 5: Targeting
After so much effort, Open Banking protagonistas now could see that their dream is greeted by indifference from the mass market.
Who is performing the segmentation exercise to target and build a marketing database of early adopters to build understanding and real-world evangelists for Open Banking?
Cock-up 6: Media backlash
Already there have been press articles appearing on the security risks, data risks, and financial and social exclusion that Open Banking will introduce. As with any innovation, the naysayers scream as soon as things go badly wrong; and things will go wrong.
Is there a well-briefed PR officer out there to be the first point of contact for any media to rebut, re-present or contextualise these events?
There is now a danger to the Open Banking project. It needs to be put in the hands of a skilled PR officer, with appropriate budget. If not, the possibility exists that important regulatory intervention and lots of complex work will end up wasted. It could easily become a victim of its own tongue-tied and incoherent narrative.
-
Temenos partners with ClearBank for cloud payments
Banking software company Temenos has formed a strategic relationship with ClearBank to provide banks with a faster route to market for real-time cloud payments...
-
Unity Trust Bank registers 34% rise in profits
Unity Trust Bank increased profits by 34% in 2019...
-
Believe the hype – why explainable AI is a trend that’s here to stay
Technology has become a ubiquitous part of our day-to-day lives...
-
Piloting tech updates: ‘The bigger the bank, the harder it is to get anything done’
In the latest Medianett filmed roundtable session, we discussed how important technology is in the banking space, and what impact the industry expects it to have on its businesses in the future...
-
What banks need to know about cloud security
One of the most common perceived concerns when adopting the cloud is the issue of security...
-
OakNorth sees 95% increase in pre-tax profits
OakNorth Bank has announced a 95% rise in pre-tax profits in 2019 to £65.9m, up from the £33.9m recorded in 2018...
-
Redwood Bank signs up to Women in Finance Charter
Redwood Bank has announced that it has signed up to the Women in Finance (WIF) Charter...
-
Masthaven launches digital Women in Leadership programme
Masthaven Bank has launched a new Women in Leadership digital development programme for female senior leaders...
-
Protecting against supply chain disruption and the domino effect
Disappointingly, many UK SME business owners don’t understand their supply chains...
-
Confused about which Isa to choose? Hopefully this mini-guide will help…
We are now firmly in Isa season, so you’re likely to read multiple articles about the most competitive Isa products in the market and how best to make the most of your Isa allowance before the end of the tax year...
-
Garden shed entrepreneurs contribute £16.6bn to the UK economy
Entrepreneurs who run their businesses from garden sheds contribute £16.6bn annually to the UK economy, according to a recent study...